
Missed a free trade preference? How to claim it after the goods are cleared
The goods qualified. Nobody claimed it.
A Michigan importer brings in wire harnesses from a plant in Querétaro: about 18,000 lb per truckload, produced in Mexico from components that meet the USMCA rule of origin. For six months, the broker files the entries without the "S" special program indicator, because nobody sent the certification of origin. Full duty is paid on every entry. An internal audit spots it.
The money is usually recoverable. The US, the UK and India all provide a way to claim a trade preference after the goods have been released. The routes differ in their deadlines, their paperwork and, in India's case, in an extra step that catches many importers out.
United States: PSC first, 1520(d) as the backstop
The US gives importers two tools. Before liquidation, a post-summary correction (PSC) amends the entry summary in ACE to add the preference indicator, and CBP refunds the difference at liquidation. CBP guidance expects a PSC within 300 days of the date of entry and at least 15 days before scheduled liquidation, which typically happens around 314 days after entry.
After that, the statutory route is a post-importation claim under 19 U.S.C. 1520(d), available for USMCA and most other US free trade agreements. It must be filed within one year from the date of importation and include a written declaration that the good qualified, a certification of origin and any supporting documents CBP requests. If CBP denies the claim, the importer can protest under 19 U.S.C. 1514.
One limit matters in practice: the US has no Generalized System of Preferences in force since the program lapsed at the end of 2020, so 1520(d) is relevant for FTA partners, not for former GSP sources. Our guide to importing into the United States covers the entry process itself.
United Kingdom: three years and form C285
The UK-EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement requires each side to accept a preference claim after importation for at least three years. HMRC handles the repayment through form C285, which must be filed within three years of the import declaration. The claim relies either on a statement on origin made out by the EU exporter, which can be issued after export, or on importer's knowledge, where the importer holds the production and costing evidence that proves origin.
Importer's knowledge is convenient at entry but harder to defend later: if HMRC asks, the evidence must already be in your file. Our article on importing into the UK after Brexit explains how the TCA rules of origin work.
India: reassess first, then claim the refund
India adds a procedural step. In ITC Ltd v. Commissioner of Central Excise (2019), the Supreme Court held that a refund cannot be granted against a self-assessed bill of entry that has not been modified. The importer must therefore first seek reassessment, through an amendment under section 149 of the Customs Act, 1962, or an appeal under section 128, generally within 60 days of the assessment. Only then does the refund claim under section 27 follow, within one year from the date of payment.
Two further points apply. Under the CAROTAR 2020 rules, the importer must be able to show the origin information on which the claim rests. And section 27 applies the unjust enrichment test: if the duty was passed on to the buyer, the refund goes to the Consumer Welfare Fund rather than to the importer.
| Market | Route | Deadline | Main trap |
|---|---|---|---|
| US | PSC before liquidation | 300 days from entry | Liquidation closes the window |
| US | 19 U.S.C. 1520(d) | 1 year from importation | FTA goods only |
| UK | C285 repayment | 3 years | Importer's knowledge evidence |
| EU | UCC art. 117 | 3 years | Proof of origin issued retrospectively |
| India | s. 149 or s. 128, then s. 27 | 1 year from payment | No reassessment, no refund |
Three worked examples
Rates and values below are working assumptions; check the exact rate for each tariff line.
Michigan harnesses. Six months of entries total $1.2 million. At an assumed MFN rate of 2.6% for HTS 8544.42, the overpaid duty is $31,200. The oldest entries are about 180 days old, so all of them are still open for a PSC. Filing PSCs now avoids the heavier 1520(d) file. Any additional duties layered on top of MFN that USMCA status removes would increase the amount; check which apply to your entries.
Birmingham shirts. A UK retailer imports £95,000 of cotton shirts made in Portugal, cleared at an assumed 12% because the invoice lacked a statement on origin. Duty paid: £11,400. The Portuguese exporter issues a statement on origin, and the importer files a C285. Import VAT was also £2,280 higher, but a VAT-registered business already recovered it.
Chennai machinery parts. An Indian importer brings in ₹80 lakh of parts from the UAE without a CEPA certificate. Basic customs duty at an assumed 7.5% is ₹6 lakh, plus a 10% social welfare surcharge on it, ₹60,000. The certificate arrives two months later. The importer requests amendment under section 149, obtains reassessment at the CEPA rate, then files under section 27. IGST credit makes the IGST share largely neutral.
See what the preference is worth per shipment
Run the same product and value at the MFN rate and at the preferential rate. The gap is what a missing certificate costs you on every entry.
Run the calculation →Building the claim into the process
A retrospective claim is a repair, not a strategy. Request the origin document with the commercial invoice, make it a condition of payment, and check it before the vessel or truck arrives. Where your supplier certifies origin regularly, a blanket certification covering up to twelve months, permitted under USMCA, removes the shipment-by-shipment risk.
When a claim is unavoidable, assemble the file before filing rather than in response to questions: the entry or bill of entry numbers, the commercial invoices, the origin document with its issue date, the supplier's bill of materials or the rule-of-origin analysis behind it, and proof that the goods shipped directly or under the agreement's transit rules. A claim that arrives complete is typically processed faster and draws fewer follow-up requests.
Do not confuse this route with the refund for faulty goods. A missed preference is an overpayment on conforming goods; duty on rejected or defective goods follows different rules and shorter clocks, covered in our article on getting duty back on defective imports.
Keep the origin file as if you expected an audit, because a late claim often triggers one. The EUR.1 certificate guide shows what a robust origin file looks like for EU trade.
Frequently asked questions
Should I file a PSC or a 1520(d) claim in the US?+
If the entry has not liquidated and you are within the post-summary correction window, a PSC is usually the simpler route: it corrects the entry summary directly. CBP guidance expects a PSC within 300 days of the date of entry and at least 15 days before the scheduled liquidation date. Once that window closes, a post-importation claim under 19 U.S.C. 1520(d) remains available for up to one year from the date of importation.
Do I need a certificate of origin to claim USMCA after entry?+
USMCA does not prescribe a form: a certification of origin with the minimum data elements, completed by the importer, exporter or producer, is enough. For a 1520(d) claim, you also submit a written declaration that the good qualified at the time of importation and any supporting documents CBP requests.
How long do UK importers have to claim a preference retrospectively?+
Under the UK-EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement, the importing party must allow a claim after importation for at least three years. In practice, UK importers use form C285 for the repayment, within the three-year limit, and must hold the statement on origin or the importer’s knowledge evidence on which the claim is based.
Why was my Indian refund claim rejected even though the origin was valid?+
Since the Supreme Court ruling in ITC Ltd v. Commissioner (2019), a refund under section 27 of the Customs Act cannot be granted against a self-assessed bill of entry unless that assessment is first modified, by amendment under section 149 or by appeal. Filing the refund claim alone is typically rejected.
Does claiming a preference late increase audit risk?+
It can. A late claim with a freshly issued certificate invites a verification request to the exporting country. If the origin does not hold up, the refund is denied and earlier preference claims from the same supplier may be reviewed too.
Marie Fontaine
Marie leads customs research at TRADE-COST. She spent eight years in tariff classification and post-clearance audits before joining the product team to turn customs expertise into software.
Calculate your landed cost in 30 seconds
Duties, VAT, freight, insurance and margin — one form, one complete result.
Try the calculator →The TRADE-COST newsletter
Once a month: our analyses on customs, freight, and changes in international trade rules. No spam, one-click unsubscribe.
By subscribing, you agree to receive our emails. One-click unsubscribe from every email.
Related articles
Battery Due Diligence Slipped to 2027. The QR Code Did Not
Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 runs three different clocks: due diligence pushed to 18 August 2027 by Regulation (EU) 2025/1561, an Article 7 carbon footprint declaration waiting on a delegated act that still does not exist, and a firm 18 February 2027 QR code. Plus the EUR 40m threshold, the US state EPR patchwork, and the GB/Northern Ireland split.
Digital Product Passport: the one deadline that is already fixed
The digital product passport is treated as a 2030 problem. It is not: the battery passport binds on 18 February 2027 (Reg. (EU) 2023/1542, art. 77). Exact scope, who carries the duty on import, the ESPR 2025-2030 plan, plus the UK, US and India positions.
GPSR: no EU responsible person, no EU sale
Regulation (EU) 2023/988 has applied since 13 December 2024: technical documentation kept 10 years, an email address required on the product, 2 working days for a marketplace to act on an authority order. What US, UK and Indian sellers must put in place, with numbers.