Skip to main content
Defective imports: how to get the duty back on rejected goods
Customs6 min read

Defective imports: how to get the duty back on rejected goods

By
Lead Customs Analyst · at TRADE-COST

The goods failed inspection. The duty did not come back on its own.

A furniture importer in Columbus, Ohio, lands 4,000 mesh office chairs from Guangdong. On the warehouse floor, the quality team finds that 600 of them have cracked gas-lift housings. The supplier agrees to credit the units. Nobody in the warehouse thinks about the duty already paid on those 600 chairs, including the Section 301 tariff that, on this product, can be several times the freight bill.

That duty is recoverable, but only if the importer follows a specific sequence before the chairs are scrapped or sent anywhere. The US, the UK and India all offer relief for rejected or defective imports, and they differ sharply on deadlines, on what counts as use, and on the paperwork that must be filed before the goods move.

United States: rejected merchandise drawback, 19 U.S.C. 1313(c)

Rejected merchandise drawback refunds 99% of the duties, taxes and fees paid on imported goods that, at the time of import, did not conform to sample or specifications, were shipped without the consignee's consent, or were defective. The conditions, in practice:

  • The goods are exported or destroyed under CBP supervision within five years of the date of importation (extended from three years by the Trade Facilitation and Trade Enforcement Act of 2015).
  • The importer files a Notice of Intent to Export, Destroy or Return (CBP Form 7553) before the goods move, giving CBP the chance to examine them or waive examination. In most cases the notice must be filed at least five working days before export, and longer before destruction.
  • The goods have not been used in the US beyond the inspection needed to find the defect.
  • The drawback claim is filed electronically in ACE, typically by a licensed broker with drawback experience, within five years of import.

The 99% covers ordinary duties, including Section 301 and Section 232 duties in most cases. Eligibility for certain duties imposed by executive order has varied, so check the current CBP guidance for each tariff line on the entry. With the US de minimis exemption suspended since August 29, 2025, low-value e-commerce imports now pay duty too, which makes rejected merchandise drawback relevant to sellers who never used it before.

US, UK and India side by side

CountryLegal basisRefundDisposalDeadline
United States19 U.S.C. 1313(c)99% of duties, taxes, feesExport or destruction under CBP supervision5 years from import
United KingdomRejected imports reliefImport duty (VAT via return)Export or destruction under HMRC supervisionTypically 1 year
IndiaCustoms Act 1962, s. 26AImport duty paidRe-export, destruction or relinquished title1 year from payment
European UnionUCC art. 118Import dutyExit or a substitute procedure1 year

In the UK, the claim is usually filed on form C285 with evidence of the defect and of export or destruction. For a VAT-registered business, import VAT is recovered through the VAT return as usual, so the claim is mostly about the duty. In India, section 26A excludes, among others, goods that are perishable or have a short shelf life, and goods on which drawback has already been claimed; identity must be established to the satisfaction of the proper officer. The freight and handling side of sending goods back is covered in our guide to international reverse logistics.

Three worked examples

Rates and costs below are working assumptions; check the HTSUS, the UK Integrated Online Tariff or the Indian tariff for your exact code.

Example 1: the Ohio chairs. Entered value $65 per chair, so $39,000 for the 600 defective units. Base duty on these chairs: 0% (assumption, heading 9401). Section 301 duty: 25% (assumption, List 3), or $9,750. Rejected merchandise drawback returns 99%: $9,652. Each chair weighs about 40 lb, so 24,000 lb of scrap. Destruction under CBP supervision at an estimated $1,800 beats shipping a full container back to China at an estimated $4,500. Net gain: about $7,850.

Example 2: the Manchester tableware. A UK homeware retailer imports £48,000 of ceramic tableware; £12,000 of it arrives with glaze defects. At an assumed 8% import duty, that is £960. A C285 claim within the year, with export back to the supplier at an estimated £700, nets about £260. Destruction locally at an estimated £250 nets about £710. On thin margins like this, the disposal choice matters more than the refund itself.

Example 3: the Pune components. An Indian electronics assembler pays duty of roughly $8,400 on a $60,000 consignment of connectors (an assumed 14% effective rate including surcharges). A quarter of the lot fails specifications. A section 26A claim on the rejected $15,000 portion recovers about $2,100, provided the re-export happens and the claim is filed within one year of payment. Filed at month thirteen, the claim fails.

See what is at stake on a rejected lot

Enter the value and HS code: the calculator shows the duty and taxes paid on import, which is the ceiling of what a rejected goods claim can recover.

Run the calculation →

Building a claim file that holds up

A claim that survives review has five pieces: the purchase order or contract with the agreed specifications; a dated inspection report, ideally from a third party; the supplier's written acknowledgment of the defect or its credit note; the import entry with its duty breakdown; and proof of export or a destruction certificate witnessed or waived by customs. Lot numbers, serial numbers and photographs tie the rejected units to the entry, which is where many claims fail.

Destruction has its own procedure and costs, set out in our article on destruction and abandonment under customs control. And keep rejected merchandise drawback separate from the broader drawback programs for goods that are sound but exported or used in manufacturing, described in our guide to duty drawback: the filing codes and evidence differ.

The single most useful habit is to log the import date the moment a lot is quarantined, and to file the Form 7553 before anything moves. Everything else can be assembled later; a missed notice or a missed deadline usually cannot be repaired.

Frequently asked questions

Can I claim rejected merchandise drawback if I already opened and tested the goods?+

Yes. Under 19 U.S.C. 1313(c), opening, inspecting and testing goods to discover the defect is expected. What disqualifies the goods is putting them into commercial use or selling them. If some units already reached customers before the defect surfaced, treat them separately and confirm their eligibility with a licensed customs broker before filing.

Do I have to ship the goods back to the original supplier?+

No. In the US the merchandise must be exported or destroyed under CBP supervision; the destination does not have to be the seller. In the UK, rejected imports relief also allows export or destruction under HMRC supervision. Destruction is often cheaper for low-value goods, but it needs prior notice so customs can witness it or waive the examination.

How long do I have to file?+

In the US, the goods must be exported or destroyed within five years of importation and the drawback claim filed within five years of import. In the UK and India the window is typically one year from import or payment of duty, so a slow supplier dispute can cost you the refund there long before it would in the US.

Does drawback cover Section 301 duties on Chinese goods?+

In most cases, yes: Section 301 duties are ordinary customs duties for drawback purposes, so 99% can be recovered on qualifying rejected merchandise. Eligibility for some executive-order duties has differed from instrument to instrument, so check current CBP guidance (CSMS messages) for the specific duty lines on your entry before counting on the refund.

What if I keep the goods and the supplier gives me a credit instead?+

Rejected merchandise drawback requires the goods to leave or be destroyed, so a credit on goods you keep does not qualify. In the US, a price reduction may affect value only in limited circumstances; in the UK and EU, a warranty price adjustment agreed in the contract before import can reduce customs value if it is made within twelve months. Document the warranty clause either way.

About the author

Marie Fontaine

Lead Customs Analyst · TRADE-COST

Marie leads customs research at TRADE-COST. She spent eight years in tariff classification and post-clearance audits before joining the product team to turn customs expertise into software.

Calculate your landed cost in 30 seconds

Duties, VAT, freight, insurance and margin — one form, one complete result.

Try the calculator →

The TRADE-COST newsletter

Once a month: our analyses on customs, freight, and changes in international trade rules. No spam, one-click unsubscribe.

By subscribing, you agree to receive our emails. One-click unsubscribe from every email.

Related articles

Customs7 min read

Battery Due Diligence Slipped to 2027. The QR Code Did Not

Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 runs three different clocks: due diligence pushed to 18 August 2027 by Regulation (EU) 2025/1561, an Article 7 carbon footprint declaration waiting on a delegated act that still does not exist, and a firm 18 February 2027 QR code. Plus the EUR 40m threshold, the US state EPR patchwork, and the GB/Northern Ireland split.

Marie Fontaine
Read →
Customs7 min read

Digital Product Passport: the one deadline that is already fixed

The digital product passport is treated as a 2030 problem. It is not: the battery passport binds on 18 February 2027 (Reg. (EU) 2023/1542, art. 77). Exact scope, who carries the duty on import, the ESPR 2025-2030 plan, plus the UK, US and India positions.

Marie Fontaine
Read →
Customs6 min read

GPSR: no EU responsible person, no EU sale

Regulation (EU) 2023/988 has applied since 13 December 2024: technical documentation kept 10 years, an email address required on the product, 2 working days for a marketplace to act on an authority order. What US, UK and Indian sellers must put in place, with numbers.

Marie Fontaine
Read →